Peer Review Process

All manuscript submitted to Talijagad will be initially processed by Editorial Team. The editor will verify the completeness of manuscript according to author guideline and the suitability of the work to the focus and scope. If a good reception is met, the manuscript is sent to peer reviewers. The review processes are carried out using a double-blind review system which means that the author and reviewer does not know each other. For each manuscript, two reviewers will evaluate substantial contents in the manuscript. After comments from reviewers are obtained, the editor will evaluate and decide to further process or reject the manuscript. When a revision is needed, the reviewer comments will be sent to the author. The editor will then make further decision based on amendments of the author. If necessary, a second or further review process can be carried out until a final decision is made.

Furthermore, the submitted manuscripts must address scientific merit or novelty appropriate to the focus and scope. All manuscripts must be free from plagiarism contents. All authors are suggested to use plagiarism detection software to do the similarity checking. Editors check the plagiarism detection of articles in this journal by using a Turnitin software.

Final decision of articles acceptance will be made by Editors according to reviewers comments. Publication of accepted articles including the sequence of published articles will be made by Editor in Chief by considering sequence of accepted date and geographical distribution of authors as well as thematic issue.


To ensure the certainty of information on submitted manuscripts, we apply the standard service time of the journal as follows: 




Initial Peer Review (Internal Editor Review Process),

including: Focus & Scope, the Template of manuscript, Similarity Check

1-2 weeks

Peer-Review Process (double blind peer-review system)

4-8 weeks